William Katz:  Urgent Agenda

HOME      ABOUT     CONTACT 

 

 

 

 

DUMB AND DUMBER – AT 9:31 A.M. ET:   Every now and then, John Kerry proves to us why he needs an intellectual minder to travel with him and review all his statements before he makes them.  This time the proper Bostonian has really gone over the top.  From IBD:   

Secretary of State John Kerry says that global warming skeptics should be disqualified from "high public office." By all means, Secretary Kerry, let's allow you to unilaterally set the eligibility requirements for elected officials. We'll just turn it all over to you and your astute judgment.

Here's the gaseous statement that elicited our playground response, made Wednesday by Kerry from his Climate and Clean Energy Investment Forum, as recorded by Talk Radio News Service:

"But when I hear a United States senator say, 'I'm not a scientist so I can't make a judgment,' or a candidate for president for that matter, I'm absolutely astounded. I mean, it's incomprehensible that a grownup who has been to high school and college in the United States of America disqualifies themselves because they're not a scientist when they've learned that the Earth rotates on its axis, but they're not a scientist; where they've learned that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west, and it does so 24 hours a day; and you can run the list of things that we know science tells us happens, and we accept it every single day.

"And to suggest that when more than 6,000-plus peer-reviewed studies of the world's best scientists all lay out that this is happening and mankind is contributing to it, it seems to me that they disqualify themselves fundamentally from high public office with those kinds of statements."

COMMENT:  Uh, right, John.   I wonder how Kerry determined that these were 6,000 of the world's "best scientists."  Who's a "best scientist"?  In fact, some of the world's leading scientists, including the renowned Freeman Dyson at Princeton, have raised serious doubts about the theories behind "climate change." 

The history of science is filled with mistakes.  It is filled with propositions that have been accepted for generations before being proved wrong.  When I was a student at the University of Chicago I was required to take a course that explored wrong theories.  The purpose, the instructor told me, was to show students "how science proceeds." 

There was actually a serious proposal put forth recently by some scientists suggesting that those who deny climate change be prosecuted under the RICO statutes.  Yeah, let's go back to the middle ages.  Maybe we should put dissenters in dungeons, too. 

How many times in your life have you seen revisions in the preferred treatment of some diseases?  Science proceeds all the time, and sometimes the old, accepted ideas are left by the wayside.

October 22, 2015